View Single Post
 
Old 05-06-2017, 10:50 AM
airdave's Avatar
airdave airdave is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Ontario Canada
Posts: 14,254
Total Downloaded: 257.44 MB
There is a difference between "being buildable"
and whether people will want to...try to...can... build it.

First off, I have no interest in any scale larger than 1/72 for these models.
if I wanted to design something to be built at 1/32 scale, I would take an entirely different approach.
It would also be a stand alone model, as opposed to "accessories" for diorama.

These are accessory pieces with a much simpler design approach.

Thats my approach here, so I am more interested in one large package
(making it a more affordable option...considering there are already plenty of free models)
...putting as much as possible into that one package (leaving less time for each individual model)
...and focusing on the visual effect, rather than the complexity of the models.

Your skills are amazing.
I would not attempt to build the 1/50 scale Tugs at 1/144.
Even 1/100 would be difficult and frustrating for me.
Maybe not for you...but it would be for me.
And many other beginner to intermediate builders would be intimidated by this.
And "beginners/intermediate" is my target audience.
Along with the average Jet Airliner builder (who may not want to spend as much time on the accessories).

As I said, for the larger Tugs, and vehicles with larger wheels, I will consider basic 3D wheels.
I might add this option, along with 2D wheels, but only for certain models.
Its not that easy to just "modify" the model for a change like this.
Sometimes I design a body around a certain style of chassis.
It may not be easily modifiable, and might require a more extensive redesign to accept the changes.
Its sometimes easier to go back and start from scratch.

The minibox model approach is very straightforward.
The models are very boxy, with 2D wheels that are literally "boxed in".
The small scale allows for this, and the visual effect is quite acceptable.
Imagine the models tucked away within a large railroad layout..
I think the point is a very quick and simple model...not just for paper modellers.

But... for someone who wants a bit more complex model, this style may not satisfy.
I get it.
I am trying to strike a balance between more detailed and realistic models
and simplicity, ease of build, and less parts.
And as always I try to design "for the beginner"...not the skilled modeller.
I have to keep that in mind.
__________________
SUPPORT ME PLEASE: PaperModelShop
Or, my models at ecardmodels: Dave'sCardCreations
Reply With Quote